Elitism: The Democrats Self-Inflicted Wound?

[This article is the first in a series on Elitism, Conservatives and Progressives.]

I have been meaning to get my ideas straight on elitism for some weeks now, but little did I realise how central it was to so many philosophical issues that I am talking about on this blog. The catalyst for this series of articles was my previous article on Obama’s Appalachian problem, which I thought was explained brilliantly by Senator Jim Webb. Webb is an Appalachian of Scottish-Irish descent, the very demographic that has been causing so many problems for Obama. I will return to the attitudes of progressive elites to the ‘racism’ of the Appalachians later.

One of the clearest explanations of Elitism in US politics was written by Jonathan Chait in a short article, Popular Will, where he says:

Since blue-collar whites have been trending Republican, conservatives enjoy a presumptive affinity and have taken it upon themselves to police the political culture for any affronts against their favored class. The rules of the game, understood now by all sides, hold that elitism is defined entirely in social, rather than economic, terms. Thus Obama’s attempts to highlight his (relative) lack of wealth did not win him any points. Nor did McCain’s campaign manager, Rick Davis, attract any criticism when he called Obama an “elitist” within a few days of convening a gathering of Washington lobbyists at Johnny’s Half Shell on Capitol Hill.

On the other hand, McCain did stir up a bit of negative publicity when bloggers discovered that what his campaign website billed as Cindy McCain’s recipes turned out to be copied verbatim from the Food Network. To be down with the working class, you needn’t represent its political interests or even share its lifestyle. You simply have to be able to convincingly imitate its social customs.

I recommend everyone who hasn’t done so read the whole article. Chait makes clear that there is an enormous amount of hypocrisy bound up in the issue which makes me curious about the causes of this ‘elitism’ charge that the Republicans stick to the Democrats so successfully. Are the Democrats doing anything to deserve this abuse (Republicans being just as elitist)? And to what extent is Barack Obama culpable for attracting this charge of elitism (apart from his poorly-chosen ‘bitter’ words)?

Next: Conservatives and Progressives


One response to “Elitism: The Democrats Self-Inflicted Wound?

  1. Republicans do want to make working-class voters pay a higher proportion of the tax burden, restrain popular social programs, erode the value of the minimum wage, and so on.

    Don’t count on the popularity of those social programs. Welfare is more popular among wealthy elites than it is among the working class. Working class people are closer to the realities of social dysfunction, which welfare mostly exacerbates.

    And the minimum wage is a feel good measure. It is so low that most low skill entry level jobs begin significantly higher than minimum.

    There are hosts of other reasons why working class voters do not see Democrat policies as benefitting themselves. The Dems are solidly in the pocket of the teacher’s unions, which are opposed to most reforms that would make the education establishment more accountable for school performance. They are also beholden to unions in general, which most working class people do not favor.

    The elitism comes from an attitude among Democrat policy makers that working class status equals victimhood, and that workers are resentful of wealth and looking for government to redistribute wealth to them. Most working class people do not want to become needy dependents, which is how Dems look at them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s